Close this search box.

Addressing the Hidden Epidemic of Maternal Mistreatment in Maternity Care

Kimberly Turbin expected the birth of her child to be a joyful moment, a culmination of a healthy and uncomplicated pregnancy. However, her experience in the delivery room turned traumatic, leaving her with lasting emotional scars—a scenario far too common in maternity care across the globe.

Turbin’s story is not isolated. An unsettling percentage of mothers report experiencing mistreatment by healthcare professionals during one of the most vulnerable periods of their lives. This can range from neglect and verbal abuse to physical harm and coercion into medical procedures without consent, such as in Turbin’s case where she was subjected to repeated episiotomies despite her objections.

The Prevalence of Disrespect and Abuse

Research indicates that one in five mothers in the United States experiences some form of mistreatment during childbirth, with even higher rates among women of color, those on public insurance, or without insurance. These interactions not only violate the dignity of women but can also have serious physical and psychological consequences.

Mistreatment in maternity care is linked to increased risks of complications like obstructed labor and excessive bleeding. Psychologically, it heightens the likelihood of postpartum depression and can trigger childbirth-related post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), further complicating the postpartum period and affecting the mother’s ability to bond with and care for her infant.

Why This Matters

The implications of such treatment extend beyond the individual. Disrespect and abuse in maternity care undermine trust in the healthcare system, deterring women from seeking necessary prenatal and postnatal care. This can exacerbate health disparities and negatively impact maternal and infant health outcomes.

Moreover, the trauma can have ripple effects across families and communities. It can hinder the development of a healthy parent-child relationship, essential for the emotional and physical development of the child. Studies suggest that the stress and depression associated with such traumatic experiences can even have intergenerational impacts.

The Path Forward

Addressing this issue requires a multifaceted approach:

  • Education and Training: Medical professionals need better training to handle childbirth in ways that respect women’s autonomy and acknowledge their individual needs and circumstances.
  • Policy Changes: Clear policies must be enacted to prevent mistreatment and hold perpetrators accountable. This includes laws and hospital protocols that prioritize patient consent and provide clear recourse for women who experience mistreatment.
  • Support Systems: Enhancing support systems such as counseling for new mothers, peer support groups, and advocacy programs can help women recover from traumatic childbirth experiences.
  • Aware World Health Organization (WHO) and United Nations recognition: The mistreatment of women during childbirth is recognized as a human rights violation, calling for global awareness and action.

Advocacy and Change

Individual stories like Turbin’s highlight the urgent need for systemic change. Her bravery in speaking out and pursuing legal action has shed light on this critical issue, prompting discussions about the need for more compassionate and respectful maternity care.

Women’s health advocates are pushing for changes at both the institutional and legislative levels. They are working to ensure that all women have a right to dignified, respectful care during childbirth. Education campaigns are also essential to empower women to know their rights and what constitutes acceptable and unacceptable care.


The issue of mistreatment in maternity care is complex, rooted in both cultural attitudes and systemic healthcare failures. By understanding and addressing these underlying factors, we can work towards a healthcare environment that ensures safe, respectful, and empowering care for all mothers. It’s not just about improving individual experiences—it’s about transforming maternity care for the betterment of society as a whole.

This is not just a women’s issue; it’s a societal issue that affects the well-being of families and communities everywhere. It’s crucial that this problem receives the attention and action it deserves to prevent more women from undergoing the traumatic experiences that Kimberly Turbin and countless others have endured.