Close this search box.

Congress Urged to Intervene as Auto Industry Prioritizes Profits Over People and Privacy

In a revealing and concerning analysis, a recent report by the United States Senate Finance Committee has brought to light how some major automakers are compromising not just the privacy and safety of American drivers but also basic human rights in their operations. The findings call for immediate congressional action to curb these unethical practices that place profits above people.

Revelations of Human Rights Violations

The Senate’s investigation has uncovered that prominent auto manufacturers like BMW, Jaguar, Land Rover, and Volkswagen have been importing vehicles and spare parts that are allegedly produced using forced labor. This labor is primarily carried out by Uyghurs and other minority groups detained in camps in China since 2017. Such actions not only violate international human rights standards but also contravene the Tariff Act of 1930 and the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act of 2021.

The disturbing aspect of these revelations is not just the use of forced labor but the longstanding nature of these practices. Despite receiving substantial financial support through subsidies and tax relief from federal, state, and local governments, these automakers have continued their partnerships with Chinese suppliers implicated in severe human rights abuses.

China’s Growing Influence and Threat

The influence of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in global markets and its ambitions to become the world’s leading power are well-documented. The CCP’s disregard for human rights, coupled with its aggressive tactics in intellectual property theft and cyber warfare, poses significant risks, not just to individual rights but to global security.

The Privacy Dilemma: Cars as Data Goldmines

The shift towards “connected” cars has transformed vehicles into rolling data centers, capturing vast amounts of information about drivers’ habits, locations, and even preferences. This data, while potentially enhancing user experience and vehicle functionality, has also become a lucrative revenue stream estimated to potentially generate up to $750 billion for the auto industry. This shift has led to new privacy concerns, particularly as it becomes evident that some automakers are selling this data to other industries like insurance, often without clear consent from consumers.

National Security at Risk

The Mozilla Foundation’s study highlighted that major car brands are failing to protect consumer privacy adequately. Additionally, a report from The New York Times exposed how some automakers are quietly profiting from selling user data. These practices not only compromise individual privacy but also national security, making personal data vulnerable to foreign adversaries.

As early as 2016, the U.S. Attorney General’s Office warned that connected cars could become targets for state-sponsored cyberattacks. Despite these warnings, the auto industry has shown little initiative in bolstering cybersecurity measures. The result has been a dramatic increase in targeted cyberattacks within the industry, growing by nearly 400 percent year over year.

Urgent Need for Congressional Action

The Senate Finance Committee has correctly pointed out that the auto industry has shown itself incapable of self-regulation. It is imperative for Congress to step in and enforce existing laws against the use of forced labor more stringently. Additionally, there is a pressing need for comprehensive data privacy legislation that not only addresses concerns related to Big Tech but also considers the unique risks posed by the auto industry’s data collection practices.

Protecting Americans and Their Data

Given the scale of data collected by modern vehicles, it is critical that this information is safeguarded against misuse, particularly by foreign entities with malicious intentions. Congressional action is needed to ensure robust privacy protections are in place to prevent misuse of data and to protect the integrity of American technology and national security.


As the auto industry continues to evolve, incorporating more sophisticated technologies and data capabilities, it must not lose sight of its ethical responsibilities. Congress must act swiftly to ensure that the industry adheres to the highest standards of human rights and data protection. Only through decisive legislative action can we ensure that the automotive sector respects the privacy and safety of individuals while contributing positively to national and global security.