Close this search box.

How Much Do Americans Really Need to Live Comfortably?

As the cost of living continues to rise sharply, many Americans find themselves recalibrating what it means to live comfortably. A survey conducted by Bankrate reveals that on average, Americans believe they need to earn about $186,000 per year to feel financially secure. But is this six-figure sum truly sufficient to meet the rising expenses of housing, healthcare, and other necessities?

The perception of necessary income varies significantly across different groups. Men reported needing more to feel secure, estimating their required income at $197,000, compared to $176,000 for women. There’s also a noticeable disparity among racial groups, with white Americans suggesting $171,000, while Black Americans feel they require a much higher $282,000 to achieve financial comfort.

This divide extends into age demographics as well, according to Bankrate’s findings:

  • Gen Z individuals estimate a needed income of $200,000
  • Millennials are close behind with $199,000
  • Generation X members believe they need around $183,000
  • Baby Boomers think $171,000 would suffice

These figures raise a critical question: Are these salary aspirations realistic for living comfortably across various parts of the U.S.? To address this, the personal finance website SmartAsset examined data from the MIT Living Wage Calculator alongside the 50/30/20 budgeting rule. This rule suggests that 50% of your income should cover necessities, 30% should go towards wants, and 20% should be allocated for savings and debt repayment.

Their findings indicate a stark contrast in living costs depending on geographic location. For example, states in the South and Midwest are generally more affordable, while the coasts present a higher financial burden. Massachusetts emerged as the priciest state, requiring an average salary of just over $116,000 to live comfortably. In New York City, the figure rises to approximately $138,500.

Interestingly, both of these estimates fall below the ideal $186,000 identified in Bankrate’s survey. This discrepancy becomes even more pronounced when considering household compositions. For a family of four, the necessary income to avoid living paycheck to paycheck can soar to $235,000 in major cities, a significant leap from the nearly $68,500 estimated last year by SmartAsset.

Despite these insights, only a small fraction of the populace—6% of those surveyed—reported earning their desired income to feel financially secure. Moreover, a concerning 18% of Americans believe they will never earn enough to live comfortably, while 31% consider it unlikely that they will ever reach their financial comfort threshold.

Given these apprehensions, Bankrate’s senior economic analyst, Mark Hamrick, advises a more frugal approach to personal finance. He recommends maintaining a strict budget, living within your means, and saving diligently for both immediate needs and future aspirations. Hamrick warns against the allure of material possessions, which often detracts from long-term financial stability and personal satisfaction.

“Overspending on luxury items like upscale homes, high-end vehicles, or the latest gadgets can undermine your financial goals,” Hamrick notes. “Instead, focusing on practical spending and saving can lead to a more fulfilling and secure lifestyle.”

This conversation about income needs versus realistic earnings highlights a broader issue within our economy—how individuals from various backgrounds perceive financial security and what they actually need to live comfortably in an ever-changing economic landscape. As prices continue to rise, finding a balance between earning, spending, and saving becomes not just a personal challenge, but a societal one.